PDA

View Full Version : The difference between the coaches


phxcat
12-02-2007, 02:52 PM
(This is sort of a follow-up to Auer's thread from last night about Stoops' lack of poise.)

If Stoops could take anything from this game, I'd ask him to look at one thing: How Erickson reacted when Williams dropped the easy TD.

Erickson looked down at his play chart, and calmly called the next play for Williams.

Can you imagine Stoops' reaction had one of our players dropped that pass?

To me, that's the main difference between the coaches right now. That move by Erickson shows the ability to do two things that Stoops appears, from the perspective of my couch, to regularly struggle with during games: (i) mentally getting past bad plays (or calls, by the officials or his staff) and, partly for that reason, (ii) empowering players. Both of these issues are obviously absolutely key to being a good HC.

Once you decide which players are the ones you want on the field, you cannot IMO make in-game playing time decisions based on physical mistakes. (Effort-related mistakes are another issue.) Since physical mistakes are inevitable, you cannot punish players for them. If a guy makes regular ones, start someone else next game. But once you start someone, that player cannot live in fear of making a mistake.

If Stoops ever wants to be a great HC, IMO he needs to figure out how to mentally get past those mistakes (and those by the officials and his staff) immediately and, partly thereby, create an environment where everyone is poised, confident and focused on the next play.

tstein7240
12-02-2007, 05:15 PM
great, great post.

I have said many times that Stoops isn't a leader. This is a classic example of my argument.

Drachman
12-02-2007, 05:34 PM
Excellent post.

I think this picture sums it up nicely:


http://i7.tinypic.com/7y6d4i0.jpg

Jumbos
12-02-2007, 07:22 PM
I dont think Erikson calls the plays for asu

coeagle
12-02-2007, 07:37 PM
I really wish Stoops wouldn't complain about every little play/call. He just looks stupid doing it.

RCWildcat
12-02-2007, 09:47 PM
mental Distractions:

Thought they disappeared as a result of the "vote of confidence". Witnessed a relaxed version of Stoops for UW game, thought it was a seed change.....wrong!

What this proves is a personality that is Stubborn, this is what he is, and what he will aways be, A coach that cannot grow and mature will not be able to help his players do the same. Thats why dropped balls have been an issue thruout entire regime. Why the "little things " continue to be the ongoing issue!

The report of players advising him not to yell at them constantly. So he bent for the team. So that means he is too over-bearing or too weak and looses the team by letting them criticize him and then bending to their wishes. Therefore his demeanor IS causing problems for team because they have to be distracted enough to make adjustments for his personality.

Is he not supposed to be criticized for recruiting "his" players and teaching them how to focus? This is after all the team that Stoops built! Catching balls, running routes, DB techniques. All coachable. Remember Jefferson, all those dropped passes by other receivers as well, as you can see it has come back again, similar to the attitude Stoops has about blaming outside influences...

Stubborn problems that wont go away=Stubborn Stoops personality traits that wont go away. Stoops has not learned how to make adjustments so he looks for people to yell at! If players mimic the coach then they too will look to blame events and other players, instead of looking within.

If Dykes is showing the best evidence of improvement on the team, then why not retain him, and hire a great DC? (and a coach that knows how to teach focus and concentration when catching the ball) Dropped balls is one of the recurring problems thruout Stoops HC career!